
As we light the first Advent candle, the candle of hope, we do so with the prophetic words of Jeremiah ringing in our ears, “‘The days are coming,’ declares the Lord, ‘when I will fulfill the good promise I made to the people…” (Jeremiah 33:14)
These words were first spoken to those living in the aftermath of war; standing in the ashes and rubble of all they held dear. Jeremiah reminded them of God’s promise to send exactly what they longed for, one who would restore justice and bring safety. There was little proof that this “Righteous Savor” would arrive within their life time, in fact it took another 500 years before the birth of Jesus. In the meantime these people had to get up every day and begin to slowly bring about life amid the ashes.
Author, professor, and modern day theologian, Kate Bowler writes that we, like those who first heard these words of Jeremiah, find ourselves living in the “already-but-not-yet.” She is known by many as a modern day Jeremiah, one who has fought stage four colon cancer into remission and who discovered hope through a curtain of tears while standing in the ashes of life. She knows what it takes to get up each day and bring about life in the midst of a terminal diagnosis, living through horrible cancer treatments that fell profoundly short of fulfillment, and yet, she brings good news from this land of loss and desperation; there is reason for hope.
Bowler writes, there is a new hope, a new truth. She writes that the season of Advent invites us to bear witness to the hope of God’s promise being fulfilled while also bearing witness to our not so perfect lives, “God has made us for truth-telling, to have eyes that glimpse through tears at the already-and-not-yet that we live in. And at the same time, these same eyes are trained on Jesus, who embodies the compassion, restoration, and justice we long for.” *
She teaches that the only way to true life sustaining hope is by being honest with ourselves; to open ourselves to lament all that is not perfect in our lives. Truth is, the story of God’s work in the world consists both of hope and despair, not hope in the absence of despair, but hope in the face of despair and, often, through despair.
Living between the already-but-not-yet means we need to make space to lament. Lament is a biblical practice that invites us to express our sorrow, pain, or confusion. It is the act of grieving with God. By practicing this honest form of prayer we are creating a space for hope to take root despite all that isn’t perfect.*
May your Advent journey begin with an honest and truly sustainable hope,
Rev. Heather McCarrel
(Kate Bowler, The Weary World Rejoices, Advent Study. 2024; pgs. 6-7)
Photo by Gantas Vaiciulenas/Pexels







